Bunions, bunionettes and hammertoes are three distinct foot deformities that are often confused because they can occur together and share some underlying causes. A bunion affects the big toe joint, a bunionette (sometimes called a “tailor’s bunion”) affects the little toe side of the foot, and a hammertoe is a bending deformity of one of the smaller toes. Understanding which deformity — or combination — is present is the first step toward the right treatment, and for anyone still weighing up whether surgery is the right next step, Do You Need Bunion Surgery? Causes, Non-Surgical Care & Risks sets out the full picture before any decision is made.
What Is the Difference Between a Bunion, a Bunionette and a Hammertoe?
A bunion is a bony prominence that forms at the base of the big toe, where the first metatarsal bone drifts outward and the big toe angles inward toward the other toes. A bunionette is the equivalent problem on the opposite side of the foot: a deformity of the fifth metatarsal, where the bone bows outward, creating a bony prominence near the little toe. A hammertoe is different in nature rather than location; it is a bending or clawing of one of the smaller toes, rather than a shift of a metatarsal bone. All three can cause pain and footwear difficulty, but they involve different bones and joints.
How Can You Tell If You Have a Bunion or a Bunionette?
The location of the prominence is the clearest distinguishing feature. A bunion presents as a bump on the inside edge of the foot, at the base of the big toe. A bunionette presents as a bump on the outside edge of the foot, at the base of the little toe, caused by the fifth metatarsal bowing outward. Both can cause a visible prominence, occasional bursitis (inflammation of the fluid-filled sac over the bone) and pain that makes footwear uncomfortable. If there is uncertainty about which deformity is present, or whether both exist together, an X-ray and clinical assessment from a podiatrist or doctor will confirm the diagnosis.
What Causes a Hammertoe to Develop Alongside a Bunion?
A bunion deformity crowds the toe next to it, which can push that toe out of its normal position; Mr Nazir describes this as the bunion effectively giving the adjacent toe “an eviction notice.” This crowding, combined with the increased angle between the first and second metatarsal bones, creates transfer load and instability across the front of the foot. That instability causes an imbalance in the tendons and ligaments around the joints at the base of the toes, which results in the clawing or hammering seen in a hammertoe. In other words, a long-standing bunion is a recognised contributing cause of hammertoe formation, not simply a coincidental finding.
Is It Common to Have a Bunion and a Hammertoe at the Same Time?
Yes. As a bunion progresses, the foot generally becomes wider and less stable, and hammertoes are a recognised problem that can develop alongside the bunion and the pain around the big toe joint. This is one of the reasons bunions are not treated as a purely cosmetic issue; left untreated, the mechanical changes they cause in the foot can affect neighbouring toes over time.
What Is an Arthritic Bunion and How Is It Different?
An arthritic bunion is a bunion complicated by joint stiffness, where the cartilage within the big toe joint has also worn down. Unlike a standard bunion, where realigning the bone is usually sufficient, an arthritic bunion typically requires fusing the big toe joint or replacing it. Fusion tends to produce better long-term outcomes: movement in the joint is lost, but the result is pain relief and correction of the deformity. Distinguishing an arthritic bunion from a standard one matters because it changes the surgical options available, which is why an X-ray assessment is an important early step.
Common Misconception: Are Bunionettes Just Small Bunions?
No. A bunionette is not a smaller version of a bunion; it is a separate deformity affecting a different bone. A bunion involves the first metatarsal (big toe side), while a bunionette involves the fifth metatarsal (little toe side) bowing outward. The two can occur independently or together, and while both are typically fixed with an osteotomy, a surgical procedure that cuts and resets the bone, they are assessed and treated as distinct conditions.
How Are Bunionettes Treated Surgically?
A bunionette is typically corrected with an osteotomy, the same category of procedure used for bunions, where the bone is cut and reset into a corrected position. This can be performed using minimally invasive (keyhole) surgery, in which a small screw is used to fix the bone securely in its new position. As with bunion surgery, the specific technique chosen depends on the severity of the deformity and the individual patient’s foot structure.
What Are the General Treatment Options for Bunions and Bunionettes?
Treatment for both bunions and bunionettes usually falls into one of two surgical categories: minimally invasive osteotomy or traditional open osteotomy. Both approaches cut and realign the affected bone; the difference lies in incision size, soft tissue disruption and, typically, recovery experience. Non-surgical measures, such as adjusted footwear, can help manage symptoms and may slow progression, but they do not reverse the underlying bone deformity.
Can Hammertoe Surgery Be Done at the Same Time as Bunion Surgery?
Yes. Keyhole bunion surgery and minimally invasive hammertoe correction are often carried out together in the same procedure, since the two deformities frequently coexist and share a common mechanical cause. Combining both corrections in a single operation avoids a second recovery period and addresses the forefoot instability driving both problems at once. Patients considering surgery for a bunion who have also noticed a smaller toe beginning to bend or claw should raise this during assessment, so both issues can be evaluated together.
Will a Bunion Keep Getting Worse If Left Untreated?
Bunions progress gradually over several years rather than appearing suddenly. Progression can be slowed using supportive measures such as insoles, but these do not correct the underlying bone position. As the deformity advances, the foot tends to become wider and more unstable, which raises the likelihood of secondary problems such as hammertoes, and in severe cases, ulceration around the big toe and first metatarsal. This progressive pattern is why earlier assessment, rather than waiting for the deformity to worsen, is generally advisable once pain or footwear difficulty begins.
When Should Someone See a Doctor About a Bunion, Bunionette or Hammertoe?
A podiatrist or doctor should be consulted once pain develops around the big toe joint, the little toe joint, or any toe that has begun to bend or claw. Diagnosis for both bunions and bunionettes is confirmed via X-ray, which shows the degree of bone angulation and any joint involvement. Most people first present with pain or footwear difficulty rather than cosmetic concern, and this pain is a reasonable trigger for assessment rather than something to tolerate indefinitely.
Key Takeaways
Bunions, bunionettes and hammertoes are distinguished primarily by location and type of deformity: bunions affect the big toe side, bunionettes affect the little toe side, and hammertoes are a bending deformity of the smaller toes often driven by the instability a bunion creates. All three are diagnosed with a clinical examination and X-ray, and all three can usually be addressed with an osteotomy, performed either as minimally invasive or open surgery. Understanding the different types of bunions and how they interact is essential for effective treatment. Where a bunion and a hammertoe coexist, correcting both in a single procedure is a recognised approach. Patients unsure which deformity they are dealing with, or whether more than one is present, can book a consultation with Mr Nazir to receive a clear diagnosis and a tailored treatment plan.
